[Docs] Move the pentest module out of the shop window, keep it in the build #611

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-07-22 16:19:54 +00:00 by brenno · 1 comment

brenno commented

2026-07-22 16:19:54 +00:00

Owner

Found in the pre-publication product review.

Evidence: README.md gives the MIAUW module a paragraph of equal weight to "structured slide editors", naming CVSS 4.0, a CWE picker, sealing, RFC 3161, an AES-256 dossier and compliance scoring in one breath. The module itself is well built: lib/state/info_safety_provider.dart:20-22 — one switch, off by default, all reference data baked in, no network egress.

Why this matters now: the question is not whether the module ships — it should, it is gated, offline and costs the ordinary user nothing. The question is whether it belongs in the shop window. Right now it determines the answer to "who is this for": a reader sees a penetration-test reporting suite that also happens to make slides, and concludes the product does not know itself. That is the mechanism by which "too much, too early" becomes the first public verdict.

The shop-window slot belongs to the privacy scan plus redaction at the projection boundary. That is genuinely unusual, and it is the one feature no competitor has.

Proposal: split the feature list in two: eight bullets of "what it is" with the privacy scan as the second line, then a heading "Specialist modules (off by default)" with MIAUW, AI assistance and git storage in one sentence each plus a link.

A candidate one-liner for the front page: "A Marp presentation editor that runs on your device and reads your deck back to you before you hand it over — it spots personal data and removes it at the projection boundary, while your Markdown keeps the original."

Found in the pre-publication product review. **Evidence:** `README.md` gives the MIAUW module a paragraph of equal weight to "structured slide editors", naming CVSS 4.0, a CWE picker, sealing, RFC 3161, an AES-256 dossier and compliance scoring in one breath. The module itself is well built: `lib/state/info_safety_provider.dart:20-22` — one switch, off by default, all reference data baked in, no network egress. **Why this matters now:** the question is not whether the module ships — it should, it is gated, offline and costs the ordinary user nothing. The question is whether it belongs in the shop window. Right now it determines the answer to "who is this for": a reader sees a penetration-test reporting suite that also happens to make slides, and concludes the product does not know itself. That is the mechanism by which "too much, too early" becomes the first public verdict. The shop-window slot belongs to the privacy scan plus redaction at the projection boundary. That is genuinely unusual, and it is the one feature no competitor has. **Proposal:** split the feature list in two: eight bullets of "what it is" with the privacy scan as the second line, then a heading "Specialist modules (off by default)" with MIAUW, AI assistance and git storage in one sentence each plus a link. A candidate one-liner for the front page: *"A Marp presentation editor that runs on your device and reads your deck back to you before you hand it over — it spots personal data and removes it at the projection boundary, while your Markdown keeps the original."*

brenno added the

docs

label

2026-07-22 16:19:54 +00:00

brenno referenced this issue from a commit

2026-07-22 17:07:09 +00:00

docs(readme): een voorpagina die in tien seconden te lezen is (#582 #590 #591 #611 #619 #620 #621 #635)

brenno referenced this issue from a commit

2026-07-22 17:12:52 +00:00

docs(readme): een voorpagina die in tien seconden te lezen is (#582 #590 #591 #611 #619 #620 #621 #635)

brenno referenced this issue

2026-07-22 17:14:10 +00:00